Solution for part 3 of homework #1






f and g are two strictly increasing functions (for n >0) and they have no inflexion point (the second order derivative never equals 0 for n>0), which means they have 0, 1 or 2 intersection points. On a plot of the two functions, one can see that they have two intersection points. We donít need the exact values since n is an integer. From the graph, we conclude that f(n) > g(n) when: 1< n < 23.


From the equivalence relation shown above:

holds when 1< n < 23.



1st method:


2nd method:

It is a known result that: when

It is true in particular when

†††††††††††† because O( ) notation allows multiplication


3rd method



Therefore, for values of n superior to 4, the function f is decreasing. On top of that:


We can conclude:


What we have proved by the last relation is exactly:

††††††††††† (above we have n0 = 4 and c =1)



Nothing can be said about the relative performance of the two algorithms. O(n^3) could mean n^1/2 as well as n^3.




1st method:


We have proved here that:

††††††††††††††††††† n0 = 0 and c= 1


2nd method:




1st method:


2nd method:

Suppose I have n0 and c such that:


This last proposition doesn't make sense, so the supposition must be false.